You might imagine that if a city proposed manufacturing snow out of reclaimed wastewater, for use at a nearby ski area, that some people might have a problem with it. After all, it might be considered a tad distasteful to ski down a pristine white slope — made from toilet water and other treated effluent.
On the other hand, such a plan makes environmental sense in an arid place that can’t afford to dump water indiscriminately.
A plan to do just this has caused major headaches for the city of Flagstaff, Arizona, but not because of health concerns.
Native tribes in the area have been battling additions to the Snowbowl ski area for years on the grounds that any development desecrates the mountains there, which they regard as sacred ground. Most recently, Hopi and Navajo leaders sued over the reclaimed-water-as-snow idea.
Because the manufactured snow will be made of recycled water drawn from a treatment facility in Flagstaff, where wastewater from “homes, hospitals, and even funeral parlors is processed, the Navajo and Hopi believe it contains impurities that will taint the mountain,” according to the Christian Science Monitor.
Now, the U.S. Department of Agriculture has stepped in … to negotiate the use of potable water in the snow-making process.
Officials, including both Arizona senators, object strongly to the added expense — some $11 million over 20 winters — and they also point out that this would violate court decisions that have said it’s okay to make snow at Snowbowl from treated wastewater.
The negotiations, revealed Monday by the Arizona Daily Sun, involve city officials and the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which has withheld permission for Snowbowl to build while it negotiates with the tribes to attempt to arrive at a compromise.
U.S. Sens. John McCain and Jon Kyl blasted the U.S. Department of Agriculture in a letter Monday, though they each support snowmaking at Arizona Snowbowl. They called for Agriculture to grant Snowbowl permission to build “immediately.”
“We oppose the use of taxpayer dollars to subsidize snowmaking at Arizona Snowbowl, and we will object to any attempt to secure an earmark or congressional approval of this project,” they wrote.
The potable water source being proposed isn’t strictly fresh water. It’s called “stored” water, which is located underground and downstream of the water treatment plant, and is mixed with natural surface and groundwater.
It’s entirely possible that the Hopi and Navajo will have a problem with that, too.